XF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?

Why are they all ganging up on him? He makes the songs his own and he can hit the notes... the judges always want someone different..he is! Who cares about his personal life, fact is he has talent.



Maybe he should come out with a sob story or cry on stage to get some sympathy off Cheryl the least.XF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?Exactly I totally agree so much with you. Matt is amazing! He has the X Factor and I want him to win.

Belle Amie's time is up on the show.XF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?
Because Simon and Cheryl are tossers and are seriously threatened by Matt. He called chers performance the best of the series, what is that man on??? And how obvious is it that he's trying to get into tweedys pants? Matts version of bleeding love was great and I was glad that Dannii stuck up for him with the other judges comments, when he sang britney last week he was incredible, now THAT was the performance of the series, Simons needs a hearing aid and is really pissing me off actuallyXF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?Because Simon and Cheryl especially are trying to groom us on who to vote for. Cher's previous flats and weak vocals in the live shows have never been mentioned, the judges try to create a pretence of consistency with her when she isn't actually always good. They do the opposite with certain contestants like Paige and Matt by going on and on about petty points but not discussing the good.
he was given a difficult song last night and i dont think it worked it went a little crazy in parts

but bellamie were praised because their performance of 'venus' topped all their other performances so far (in my opinion and the judges said it too) so they were given good comments, but all the comments and feedback the contestants are given is usually based on comparisons between what they've done in previous weeks, not between each otherXF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?Yeah that's an idea, he could just cry on stage like Cheryl's little pets and that would work. I'm not fond of him as I don't like his 'I can't be bothered to work' attitude but at least he has some talent.



It baffles me that they see anything in Belle Amie, they're good when they sing alone but they don't gel as a group or harmonise at all!XF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?
The public who vote, probably don't even listen to the judges comments, or if they do, don't take them into consideration when voting.



They seem to be hypocrites anyway, with all of the singers, i think they are just more bothered about giving digs to annoy each other (fellow judges) than actually give constructive criticism to the singers.
You are right!. Maybe it's not 'convenient' for Matt to win this year. I'm not saying that the results are rigged but there is definite audience manipulation going on. Shame for the couple of acts who can genuinely sing. If there is any justice Matt will win. I'm not holding my breath though.XF: How can the judges praise Belle Amie ...then criticise someone like Matt?
I agree with you.



I used to hang on to Simon's every word. Now I try hard not to listen to him as most of what all the judges have to say, is nonsense.



Simon never ever praises Paije up.
Because Belle Amie are simons act and the judges are trying to keep simon on side so he wont say anything too bad about the other judges acts.
Biased opinions I suppose. No Matt doesn't need a sob story, he'll do fine as he has a large fan base and he's selling well on iTunes.
I AGREE.



and belle amie were bad but hardly got any bad comments. dannii was right, their vocals were off tune. :)
Because deep down everyone knows their is no hope for Bellend Army and they dont want to hurt their precious little feelings. Matt is a man and thus can handle it.
They are both two completly different acts. Although, you do have a point.
Agreed, i love matt x